The judge of the National Court María Tardón, who investigates whether the massive entry of irregular immigrants in Ceuta last July constituted an “attack against the integrity of Spain” and could affect the peace or independence of the State, already pointing to possible sabotage of communications by Morocco to block Spain’s response to the invasion.
In her latest resolution, to which LA RAZÓN has had access, the judge has ordered the General Information Commissariat of the National Police to prepare a report detailing the “incidents” recorded that may be attributable to an intentional action to “disturb” the response capacity of Spanish public services.
The judge wants to shed light on a possible “hybrid” war, which would reinforce that the invasion that the Government denies did occur, following the witness statement of a Police officer. This command explained in court that during the days coinciding with the events investigated, the operational communications used by the police services presented “serious operational deficiencies, characterized by delays, interruptions and transmission difficulties that lasted for several days.”
This circumstance, Tardón details, was perceived by the witness as something “anomalous, to the point of raising the suspicion that these incidents could be related to the events that were simultaneously taking place on the border.
Communications failures
Although the Prosecutor’s Office details that this assessment may constitute a “subjective assessment of the declarant” and that it could have been due to a technical cause derived, precisely, from the border saturation, it has requested as measures to also obtain the opinion of the National Intelligence Center (CNI), the National Cryptological Center, the Information Headquarters of the Civil Guard and the Joint Cyberspace Command to determine who is behind the communications failures that were recorded in the key hours of the immigration assault.
Tardón refuses to carry out the proceedings for now but considers that clarifying this issue is of great importance if one takes into account that we are facing events that “directly” affected the essential interests of the State. «The possible impact of the communications systems used by the security services constitutes a factual hypothesis directly related to the capacity of institutional reaction to the events investigated (…). The procedures are suitable, necessary and proportionate,” he justifies.
In this sense, he explains that the relevance of investigating this point must be analyzed from the perspective that the «modern scenarios of confrontation between States» have evolved towards other forms of action, which are no longer the classic mechanisms of conventional armed conflict. In fact, it says that it is no longer necessary to resort to the direct use of force to generate situations of pressure on another State and progressively erode its institutional response capacity.
Thus, he explains that Morocco was able to coordinately use instruments of diverse political, economic, technological, informational, migratory or cybernetic nature, which although they may be apparently independent actions, in reality, they can respond to the same strategic objective: “produce cumulative effects on the decision-making and reaction mechanisms of the State,” he maintains.
«Formal coverage»
The judge also holds on to the fact that the investigation has already been able to determine that the massive entry was not a “spontaneous phenomenon”but rather it was an organized process in which the immigration purpose operated only as formal coverage. In fact, it details that both the passivity of the Moroccan agents and the active attitude of others have already been proven (even directing the migrants towards the beach or pushing some of them into the sea) and the presence of police officers and senior officials in the border areas.
In this sense, it expresses that the purpose of the majority of immigrants was never to remain in Spanish territory, but rather sought to obtain a maximum impact on border management until its collapse and, having achieved the first objective, eliminate Spain’s response capacity to contain or reverse the situation.
However, the head of the Central Court of Instruction Number 3 of the National Court believes that there is still no “objective” data that allows affirms that there was sabotage by Morocco of critical communication infrastructures.